January Failings

Recruitment has been a massive talking point since Aitor left the club. Really since January when the cracks began to accelerate in growth, ignoring price tags and looking at actual value added to the team and what has been contributed.

January Failings

Boro

Rudy Gestede Aston Villa £6m; 11 apps, 9 chances created, no assists, 1 goal (v Man Utd)
Patrick Bamford Chelsea £6m; 5 apps, no chances created, no goals
Adlène Guedioura Watford £4m; 5 apps, 1 chance created, no assists, no goals
Mikael Soisalo Tampere £170,000; N/A youth player

One goal contributed from January signings and no positive impact on points total adding very little value. Would be hard to argue an improvement from letting go of Nugent and Rhodes has been made.

Swansea

Tom Carroll Tottenham Hotspur £5m; 12 apps, 11 chances created, 2 assists (3-2 Liverpool Win and 3-2 Burnley Win), no goals
Luciano Narsingh PSV Eindhoven £4m; 11 apps, 6 chances created, 2 assists (Southampton 2-1 win and 2-1 loss to Man City), no goals
Martin Olsson Norwich City £4m; 11 apps, 6 chances created, 2 goals (Leicester in 2-0 Win and Burnley in 3-2 Win)
Jordan Ayew Aston Villa £5m plus Neil Taylor; 9 apps, 1 chance created, 1 assist (Loss to Spurs), no goals

Completely different story with 12 points been directly influenced by transfer window signings. Swansea spent £18m v Boro £16m. It’s clear who got more bang for the buck.

Hull

Kamil Grosicki Rennes £7m; 10 apps, 15 chances created, 3 assists (2 assists v West Ham in 2-1 win and 1 assist v Boro in 4-2 win), no goals
Markus Henriksen AZ Alkmaar £4.5m; 14 apps, 2 chances created, no assists and no goals
Evandro Porto £1.1m; 7 apps, 10 chances created, no assists and no goals
Oumar Niasse Everton loan; 12 apps, 5 chances created, no assists, no goals
Omar Elabdellaoui Olympiakos loan; 7 apps, 2 chances created, no assists, no goals
Lazar Markovic Liverpool loan; 9 Apps, 5 chances created, no assists, 1 goal scored (4-2 win v Boro)
Andrea Ranocchia Internazionale loan; 11 apps, 2 chances created, 2 assists (2-0 win v Liverpool and 3-1 loss v Stoke), 2 goals scored (2-1 win West Ham and 3-1 loss Man City)
Alfred N’Diaye Villarreal loan 10 apps, 3 chances created, no assists and 1 goal scored (2-0 win v Liverpool)

Again a much more positive outlook for Hull from January business with 9 points won directly from involvement of new signings. Total spend £12.1m.

Burnley

Robbie Brady Norwich City £13m; 10 apps, 8 chances created, 1 assist (1-1 Draw v Hull), 1 goal scored (1-1 Draw v Chelsea)
Ashley Westwood Aston Villa £5m; 5 apps, 2 chances created, no assist, no goals
Joey Barton unattached; 13 apps, 8 chances created, no assist, 1 goal (1-0 win v Southampton)

Even Burnley who doesn’t like spending money had a very valuable transfer window with 5 points contributed to their cause.

Crystal Palace

Luka Milivojevic Olympiakos £11m; 7 apps, 4 chances created, no assists, 1 goal (3-0 win v Arsenal)
Patrick van Aanholt Sunderland £10.2m; 5 apps, 3 chances created, no assists, 1 goal (1-0 win v Boro)
Jeffrey Schlupp Leicester City £9m; 10 apps, no assists, no goals
Mamadou Sakho Liverpool loan; 6 apps, 3 chances created, no assists, no goals

Doesn’t paint clear picture as Palace have been a different team under Big Sam but even that said the new signings contributed to 6 points. They were by far the biggest spenders but can you put a tag on survival.

Bournemouth

Aaron Ramsdale Sheffield United £1m, N/A youth player

At time probably thought they had enough but a couple of injuries and they are now in free fall.

As you can see from a limited sample of stats, it is fairly clear one of the issues causing pain in Teesside at the moment stems from lack of quality, team changing signings. Little to know value was added in the window and it seems we are going to suffer for it.

The View From (Behind) The (Away) Dug-Out v Arsenal

So here is Episode 2 of this new feature, this comes after the Arsenal game on Bank Holiday Monday.

Read More