Jump to content
oneBoro Forum

Smokedsalmon

Members
  • Content Count

    792
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by Smokedsalmon

  1. All the talk is him signing a new contract. Think anyone wanting him out will be sorely disappointed.
  2. Carrick has entered the pure "if I change things I have to admit it isn't working" territory that killed off Wilder.
  3. Hit and miss is being kind - pretty consistently missed everything over the last couple of years.
  4. The concerning thing is Carrick has proven that he'd literally rather concede 6 playing this way than mix it up a bit. The inflexibility is astounding. No point having principles if the team isn't good enough to carry them out.
  5. But he's a good pro who just keeps getting better and better with age! Another 5 year deal for him! What a guy!
  6. Add Tom Glover to the Marcus Bettinelli, Joe Lumley hall of shame of *** abysmal keepers we've had the displeasure of watching drop us points time and time again.
  7. Carrick is from the school of managers coming through who massively over-complicate the game. Defensively, there hasn't been any sense of shape, organisation or aggression (ironically, other than the 2 home games against far better prem teams with 5 at the back when we actually did look really organised because we just played it simple, go figure) since he took over. They actually do not know where to be in transition, especially the midfield, it is shocking. He genuinely seems to think "just vibes it and it will be fine" as a defensive structure works out because he hasn't tried to alter
  8. Saying a player isn't good enough isn't allowed in a football discussion? Weird, weird post. As per.
  9. Not sure it's fair to say there's no ambition, but Coburn definitely needs getting rid of in the summer.
  10. His insistence on sticking to this weird 4231 two number 10 system even when making subs is surely a problem of his own making, no? Why not bring on Clarke for Forss and go to the 5-2-3 that nullified Villa and Chelsea at home to see the game out? Or put Silvera up top (who is at least quick), avoid bringing on an already injured (and ***) Coburn, and bring McNair on to go 433 and give an extra midfielder? Like for like substitutions every time.
  11. If you're making a triple sub on 77 minutes because you've got multiple injuries (to a side full of players who've spent half the season on their *** *** because we seemingly either have a voodoo curse or are not conditioning them properly) then you haven't managed the game correctly. He should know that someone like Forss (who has been "coming back from injury" for about a year) would need taking off sooner. His substitutions have consistently been the worst part of his game management. Always too late and we never, ever look better afterwards.
  12. 3 subs at once to completely ruin the flow and cohesion on the pitch leading to an immediate counter attack where everyone's out of position? Glover is dogshit don't get me wrong but it was disastrous timing.
  13. Michael Carrick substitution masterclass at work again is it?
  14. He's been great - made so many good runs and presses like an absolute monster. (Greenwood that is).
  15. The passing is nightmarishly bad at times. Sadly, they're just not good enough to play how Carrick wants. Too many teams trying to be top sides without top players. Wish we played more vertically because we've got great pace and movement up top but the balls to find them are consistently awful.
  16. We are definitely more than just 1 striker away from having a promotion ready team so I don't think throwing the kitchen sink at whoever happens to be available now is the right course of action (plus teams know we've got minimum 7m to spend now). I'd hold fire until the summer when someone we really want is available personally.
  17. I think there's an argument that if your first team are clearly all very good players then sticking a kid in to sink or swim can be tough on them. But I think right now our first team squad is very young anyway, and very average overall in ability. Hackney came in under Leo last year in our lowest period of the season post-Wilder when we were absolutely stinking the gaff out every time we played and he immediately looked head and shoulders above Howson & our other midfielders, to the point he is now very clearly the best CM at the club. If they're good enough and have the right attitu
  18. I'm not sure you can give Carrick credit for playing those players when he doesn't have a choice. That's just our squad mate. If he wasn't playing Giles, Archer, Ramsey, Hackney last year, who would he have played? If he doesn't play VDB, Hackney, Coburn, Greenwood this year, who does he play?
  19. Spot on this - really good post. Carrick's tactical inflexibility is really concerning. I was pleased to see him switch it to a back 5 against Huddersfield because it proved, if nothing else, that he has it in him. But I don't think I'm wrong in thinking that since he took over that is the first time he has ever swapped from the 4-2-3-1? I've been a bit indifferent this season because whilst I hoped to see an evolution on our style and system, it feels like we've actually lost a lot of our identity. He has tried to fit the new players into the same roles as last year and I don't thin
  20. Jonny Howson being both club captain and starting games for Boro is symptomatic of how bad the squad building has been. He should have been replaced 3 years ago - has been at the heart of some of the worst Boro teams in memory.
  21. In fairness I don't really mean the footballing side of things, I mean the life aspect of it. To move abroad on your own I'd say it's pretty young, and the job is so intense, he's under the spotlight in a way he never will have been before. Easy to forget the lads are human sometimes. I don't think he's a *** player, we just haven't seen anywhere near his best for a multitude of reasons. He'll come good. Or not. Maybe he's ***. I dunno. Gotta be positive tho.
  22. I mean it's definitely pretty young to be moving abroad and doing a job that carries as much intense pressure as this level of football. At 24 I had just finished uni and spent most days in my pants playing fifa.
×
×
  • Create New...