Jump to content
oneBoro Forum
Smogzilla

The Summer/Autumn transfers thread 2020 aka TURN DOWN FOR WHAT(more)

Recommended Posts

13 minutes ago, AnglianRed said:

I guess our academy isn't all that great after all.

Maybe I'm just naive but I thought one of the main reasons for having an academy was to produce players that could break into the first team. Now obviously, like any recruitment / training process, not EVERYONE is going to make it, but I'd have thought we'd be seeing a few more making the step up to the senior squad.

6 of our first team squad are straight from the academy, given there are only 23 players in it, that's not bad.

You could arguably count Spence and Wing too, though I wouldn't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
48 minutes ago, AnglianRed said:

I guess our academy isn't all that great after all.

Maybe I'm just naive but I thought one of the main reasons for having an academy was to produce players that could break into the first team. Now obviously, like any recruitment / training process, not EVERYONE is going to make it, but I'd have thought we'd be seeing a few more making the step up to the senior squad.

Having an academy that produces regular professional footballers in any capacity is hard enough tbh,

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am well aware of the harsh realty that a large percentage of the young lads won't be cut out to make it at the top level, or even league football at all.

What annoys me is when fans write them off based on a 5 minute run out for the 1st team or a dodgy performance here or there. How can you judge a young players ability based on that? 

Take Walker as a good example. The idea that you can say hes not gonna make it based on what we've seen so far is ludicrous. Hes barely played! Hes just secured a good loan deal to a league one club and has already opened his account. Theres definitely time for him to come good.

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Old Codger said:

image.png.ca925ab2a9e88361454ef22b0ac1c7a4.png  We have the photos Brunners   

That's the photo that convinced Gestede to come to Australia.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Brunners said:

Excuse me sir, I am not Welsh and I am contacting my lawyers right at this very moment to sue for slander!!

There is nothing wrong with being Welsh...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, TeaCider24 said:

6 of our first team squad are straight from the academy, given there are only 23 players in it, that's not bad.

You could arguably count Spence and Wing too, though I wouldn't.

Yeah, Fry and Tavernier are two of our best players.  Wood is supposed to be a really good prospect.  Coulson's had some decent moments, albeit not so much this season.  We just sold another one to Blackburn who could easily have been one of our top two goalkeeper's for a long period of time.   That's not too bad overall I'd say 👍 

I know I'm not one to talk about moaning or complaining about things, but I really don't get why people seem so quick to go after the younger lads.  Not necessarily all of them like blanket criticism but they tend to focus in on one at different times.  Spence has been getting it recently and I noticed a bit about Coulson, who has barely played this season.  Fry was last season,  along with Pears actually.  Tavernier got some grief the season before.  If Wood ends up getting a run in the side, and makes mistakes, then he'll be the next one.  And he almost certainly will make mistakes as that's all part of a young players development.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, BearSmog said:

There is nothing wrong with being Welsh...

Sounds awfully like something a Welshman would say. I'm watching you.

watching i see you GIF

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Walker Is 20 years old. If he is going to have a career at Championship he needs to have really shown something by now. If you are considered surplus to requirements at our club whose striking options are poor to say the least it does tend to indicate he hasn’t much of a chance with us. It’s a shame but we’ve seen it so many times before where young players simply don’t make the grade

  • Confused 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Having consulted my legal representatives, the estimable partnership of Messrs Haddaway and Scheidt, I have been instructed to respond to your missive with the comment of "Meh"

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Robin Johnson said:

Walker Is 20 years old. If he is going to have a career at Championship he needs to have really shown something by now.

Danny Graham was 23 before he started making a name for himself at Championship level. Walker might not make the grade here but he wouldn't be the first to leave as a young lad and then come back into the Championship so I've no idea why you're writing him off because he's 20 years old.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Robin Johnson said:

Walker Is 20 years old. If he is going to have a career at Championship he needs to have really shown something by now. If you are considered surplus to requirements at our club whose striking options are poor to say the least it does tend to indicate he hasn’t much of a chance with us. It’s a shame but we’ve seen it so many times before where young players simply don’t make the grade

he's not had enough competitive league games to progress. Was improving at MK Dons last season and seams to have strated well this year. 

Personally, I'll hold judgment until the end of this loan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys it is unrealistic to expect the whole of the academy to make the grade at Boro.

I must admit that I expect there to be a regular flow of debutants.  With Woodie in charge that tended to happen.  However Warnock and Pulis before him tend not to blood the young lads.  I'm not quite sure I understand why.

I'm sure quite a lot of the lads in the academy when they get England or other country call-ups think they are going to "make it".  That in itself leads to a belief that it will happen in some individuals.  They therefore become at risk of "switching off" and not taking on board the things they need to learn.

Having said all that I still think that not providing the pathway to the first team squad will lead to their necessary improvement being sidelined to other ambitions

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Rishworthian said:

Guys it is unrealistic to expect the whole of the academy to make the grade at Boro.

I must admit that I expect there to be a regular flow of debutants.  With Woodie in charge that tended to happen.  However Warnock and Pulis before him tend not to blood the young lads.  I'm not quite sure I understand why.

I'm sure quite a lot of the lads in the academy when they get England or other country call-ups think they are going to "make it".  That in itself leads to a belief that it will happen in some individuals.  They therefore become at risk of "switching off" and not taking on board the things they need to learn.

Having said all that I still think that not providing the pathway to the first team squad will lead to their necessary improvement being sidelined to other ambitions

Don't think it's necessarily true about Warnock. NW has already said he watched the U23s game against Leeds and was so impressed by one unnamed player he had him called up to first team training immediately.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Smogzilla said:

I am well aware of the harsh realty that a large percentage of the young lads won't be cut out to make it at the top level, or even league football at all.

What annoys me is when fans write them off based on a 5 minute run out for the 1st team or a dodgy performance here or there. How can you judge a young players ability based on that? 

Take Walker as a good example. The idea that you can say hes not gonna make it based on what we've seen so far is ludicrous. Hes barely played! Hes just secured a good loan deal to a league one club and has already opened his account. Theres definitely time for him to come good.

 

It’s not about writing his whole career off, just that judging by his games last season he’s simply not ready to be a regular here. As I said a loan was the best move for everyone, it’s up to him now to prove himself and he will get the chance to do that.

Tgeres so much more than just pure football ability, setting up for a game is almost like being in school. Taking mental notes of where you have to be on the pitch during different phases of play etc. If a player decides to take no notice then during the game they will disrupt the whole game plan. No manager will pick them.

There was one player who did an interview a couple of years ago and mentioned a manager who would stop training sessions because a player was a couple of ft away from where he wanted him. I did wonder if it was Karanka he was talking about.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Latest Posts

    • I've started getting ads that close around the entire border of the phone. So when I go to click on the circle or star to see next unread comments, I accidentally click on it. Some Gillette advert. Though this is the only issue I've had in ages.  
    • The good news is that matches are not decided on current form or there'd be no need for bookies, or anything. That's what we all love about the game its unpredictability...  If we perform we'll gain some sort of result.
    • He's been doing it every game as a bit of reverse psychology. However for this game I think a defeat is probably an accurate prediction.  Swansea are playing well and are very attacking.  We tend to struggle with teams that are fast on the counter attack. 
    • Only way to make them think twice is to start dishing out suspensions for simulation..  thought he'd been hit by a sniper
    • TUESDAY 1ST DECEMBER Cardiff City v Huddersfield Town - D Birmingham City v Barnsley - H AFC Bournemouth v Preston North End - H Derby County v Coventry City - D Queens Park Rangers v Bristol City - A Rotherham United v Brentford - A   WEDNESDAY 2ND DECEMBER Blackburn Rovers v Millwall - D Luton Town v Norwich City - A Middlesbrough v Swansea City - D Nottingham Forest v Watford - A Sheffield Wednesday v Reading - H Wycombe Wanderers v Stoke City - A
×
×
  • Create New...