Jump to content
oneBoro Forum

Recommended Posts

Is there any chance we can play the bottle top left wing against Huddersfield instead of Kamara?.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there any chance we can play the bottle top left wing against Huddersfield instead of Kamara?.

 

Don't you think that risks having our entire game plan come unscrewed? :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kamara isn't useless, far from it. But he's not a winger. And he's not a good enough first choice striker. I'm fine keeping him here as a squad player to fill in up front should there be an injury to our first choice number 9, or to bring on off the bench should we opt for two upfront later in a game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd rather see us play Kamara up front over Danny Graham. Graham offers nothing to the team when he's not poaching goals, whereas Kamara can win headers a lot of the time, hold up the play and he's a lot more mobile. For me he's definitely a better option upfront than Graham.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree and Adomah played better when Emnes was in the team also. We have really missed him linking up play as now our attacks look forced with not as much fluidity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To be fair DS that was at a time when KK was up front rather than out on the wing.

 

I agree that we do miss Marv, but I really think that given a proper run in the team Tomlin will prove himself as a far more useful player than Marv.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Absolutely MMC. Kamara is not and never will be an effective wide man. I don't think the Emnes discussion is particularly relevant in this case because Kamara hasn't played up top on his own since Emned left.

 

It's becoming plainly evident that Graham is not working in this system. Both Jukewictz and Kamara have had a certain amount of joy in that role, particularly in regard to bringing the rest of the team in to play in the final third. They both physically occupy the centre halves more effectively which means it's harder for the them to play out or clear their lines especially aerially.

 

I'd rather us not have to rely on a big man up front on his own but I don't know if this system can work any other way with the personnel we have.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Agreed Humpty. Even if he's not scoring, Kamara can win headers and hold the ball up better than Graham when he's played up front. He's of a much greater benefit to the team when he's played there than Graham is. Wouldn't be an issue if Graham was scoring, but he's not and doesn't look likely to unless he has another game like he did vs Ipswich.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I NEVER made my mind up about Emnes. I still haven't. I know he can be really good, but I still don't know what he offers on a consistent basis. Something, obviously.

 

Regardless, I don't think he wants to be here. Which is why I'm happy for us to think about offloading him in the summer. And, though he might not be quite as cultured, Tomlin is a very skilled player in that position who offers more in terms of direct assists and goals.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If no club is interested in signing Emnes in the summer then I wonder whether Karanka will think he will be able to put out a balanced and effective team with both Tomlin and Emnes in the team(as both are typically thought of as being a #10)?.

 

Emnes has hardly ever impressed me whenever I've seen him play wide(left wing or right wing) other that when he was playing for Swansea v Napoli where he played a more clever playmaking role on the right which he done well linking up play which would be similar to how he could operate on the RW in our system. Tomlin can apparently play and 3 of the advanced positions but it seems he was specifically signed to play the #10 role. The advanced 3 behind the striker need to be capable of switching positions with clever movement and crisp passing to unlock defences so the more attackers like Tomlin and Emnes we can get into the team the better(if they can fit into the system) as unfortunately out-and-out wingers like Adomah just don't seem to fit into it effectively.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think that, should Emnes stay, him and Tomlin should really be competing for one spot. And that would be excellent competition. I like Ledesma, but I don't think he can outgun those two in that position. And Butterfield is best suited as the most advanced CM in a 4-3-3 (so, though a useful squad option, not really a long-term 4-2-3-1 first teamer in my opinion). So it would be interesting if Emnes stayed. And I wouldn't be totally against it. It's also not completely inconceivable that both could start in the same interchangeable team, so long as we played a system that didn't rely on natural width from the advanced midfield trio with genuine fullback support from both sides.

 

But, like I said, If Emnes truly doesn't want to be here, we need to find a way of offloading him. Could be a classic example of man management skills coming into play...

 

As for Adomah, I see no reason why he can't fit into the 4-2-3-1 system effectively. At times he has been outstanding. On other occasions he's been very average. But there aren't many players that can put in a top class level of performance week in week out in this league. And he offers more going forward then just width and pace. We have a scapegoating culture at this club. A few weeks ago we were all singing his praises! We should be more grateful for his outstanding performances then we are for his weaker ones, so long as the work rate and effort is still there when he's not quite at his best.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And in this country we have a culture of praising work rate and effort far too much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its the Protestant work-ethnic Prowler. Its why David Cameron won't let us have more than two kids.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks to all who took part in guess the attendance game...

 

ACTUAL ATTENDANCE: 15,075

 

WINNER, WINNER, CHICKEN DINNER!

 

**OLLIE10 (14,999)**

 

JUST 76 FANS OUT, TOP JOB :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


  • Latest Posts

    • Having the long term injured back should be a big help to us. Agree with BD that it’s impossible to tell until the games get going again but having a full squad to select from should be a big plus for us. I feel sorry for Charlton fans as it looks like they have all sorts of problems that won’t be beneficial to a relegation battle.
    • I agree with what Brunners is saying here @BillyWoofs_shinpad. I think it's a bit harsh to say he clearly wasn't motivated to do the job because he never got to do the job. He also had an awful start, suffered quite a long term injury at the start and despite being this big money signing that Burnley were supposedly desperate for, nothing has actually changed. Now maybe you can say as a professional he has to get on with that but I'd be shocked to hear Burnley paid £18m or whatever it was for a 4th choice centre-back who never makes the bench, I'd be shocked if that's the promise made to him when signing, I'd be willing to stake a lot on the idea that Ben was given some reassurances of playing time that simply haven't come to fruition. That may not make him unaccountable for the entirety of the process and like you, this is largely just my opinion. And I will say on the flip side, I also think it doesn't look good that he's training with us both for him and Burnley. I also think we're a bit culpable because I don't think Gibson wanted to leave and we pushed him out after wasting a *** ton of money. Now we are being this safe haven for him as he's come back to the conclusion that he had seemingly already made before leaving; he wanted to stay and he'll do anything to come back, including using the extent of his player power to make it happen.
    • It has been hinted at in the past the Burnley bought him to replace someone who was then never sold, if Gibson had been told these are my starters and even when they're unavailable you won't get a chance he probably wouldn't have signed. according to Johnathan Walters, Gibson was a true professional during his time there Walters added: "I will start by saying Ben is an unbelievable professional, he joined for £15million from Middlesbrough when he had been in and around the England squad and he just didn't play.   "He trained unbelievably well every single day, he is so professional outside of the club, he is always doing things to keep himself on top and improve himself and obviously something has happened. "It looks like he wants to go, something has happened within the club whether it is a falling out with the manager or staff.
    • It must have been a massive shock for poor Ben when he walked into the dressing room on his first day only to find out that Sean Dyche was the Burnley manager. 
    • Just saying things how I see them, Brunners. He’s not even training with Burnley, hasn’t for months, so I don’t think he has any motivation whatsoever to play for them.  By all means disagree, but provide some sort of argument to back your reasoning. 
×
×
  • Create New...