Jump to content
oneBoro Forum
Boro Badger

Boro V Huddersfield (A) 2-2

Recommended Posts

these videos highlight how karanka isnt playing the right formation that best suits the players at the moment. Not that its a bad thing, if he believes that the players who will stay the same next season, it makes sense to keep drilling the same system into them. We just need to find the players who suit the formation, I think in the summer Karanka will have time to do this.

 

When he came in, he has transformed up from relegation candidates to mid table. We dont concede as many, and due to the formation, i.e not clicking up front (due to the players not suiting the system) we havent scored as many. Whilst initially this is a problem, i think that in building from the back, i.e being hard to beat is good. As when he gets HIS players in to suit the system, is when he should be judged. I hardly imagine that he wanted to get Graham who isnt a good players for the 1 up top option.

 

WIth the likes of Tomlin, who i believe given a good pre season + a good attacking partner up front, who makes good intelligent runs, could be useful. In addition to this, we would have two other CAM's to play with up and around there.

 

If I were Karanka, this is what I would hope for next season:

 

GK - ??

 

RB - Varga / Replacement CB - Gibson / Omeruo CB - Ayala LB -Friend

 

CDM - Chalobah & CDM ??

 

CAM - CAM- Tomlin CAM - ??

 

ST- ??

 

Obviously that is depending if we get the Chelsea lads back and if we renew Varga's loan.

 

Defensively, I think we are ok on the whole. Its sometimes when attacks break down up the top end, not killing games off, and missing chances that we fall upon our sword. Getting players who suit the system obviously goes without saying, is fundamental to next seasons success.

 

I think currently, Karanka is just treading water before the summer where he will impliment changes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont think they show karanka isnt playing the right formation.. They show one coaches view on the way things should be , im sure other coaches would have a different view

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest beamishboro

Some quick reviews...

 

Dimi 5 beaten at near post for first which was poor... otherwise nothing stellar but commanded his box ok

 

Friend 7 wasn't having any luck with his forays forward but still looked one of our best players

 

Gibson 6 not his best game... looked shaky at times and distribution awful... too many aimless punts forward to nowhere

 

Omeruo 8 mom... easily the best boro player... in a different class... had a few shaky moments but always recovered

 

Varga 5 that little @#$% adam hammill had the better of him first half... improved second... not a long term solution

 

Chalobah 6 few nice touches... too laid back though... too many mistakes... thinks he's better than he is... butterfield more effective in this role second half

 

Whitehead 7 decent defensive performance... usual couple of misplaced passes but nothing serious... could have been more forward minded on occasions

 

Butterfield 6 not his best game tonite... not a number 10 or second striker and looked more effective in the deeper role second half

 

Adomah 7 couple of goals from bad defensive errors... nearly fluffed the second blasting it straight at the keeper... one of the few willing to run at defenders

 

Ledesma 5 poor game from manny tonite... struggled to get in the game and little came off for him... looked dangerous for about 5 mins at start of second half

 

Graham 6 first half was another tireless performance chasing nothing against overwhelming odds... looked better second half with more support but not a long term solution... not a target man like juke who was more effective in this thankless role... system needs to adapt to give strikers more support or our strikers will never score

 

Tomlin 6 few nice tricks and touches early in second half but otherwise looked off the pace

 

Main 5 barely touched the ball

 

Williams 7 managed to make an impression in the 5 mins he was on the pitch with some nice touches and interplay... looks like some regular football might have had a positive effect

 

That's a joke, right?

 

if not it's the most stupid thing I've ever seen on here:D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest ziggy15

Gotta agree Beamish, stupid comment regarding Adomahs 2nd. Looks even better strike on the video than I saw at the time, and I can't see how anyone could expect Smithies to stop that. Mind you the first half of the sentence was correct, defensive errors were definitely involved.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some quick reviews...

 

Dimi 5 beaten at near post for first which was poor... otherwise nothing stellar but commanded his box ok

 

Friend 7 wasn't having any luck with his forays forward but still looked one of our best players

 

Gibson 6 not his best game... looked shaky at times and distribution awful... too many aimless punts forward to nowhere

 

Omeruo 8 mom... easily the best boro player... in a different class... had a few shaky moments but always recovered

 

Varga 5 that little @#$% adam hammill had the better of him first half... improved second... not a long term solution

 

Chalobah 6 few nice touches... too laid back though... too many mistakes... thinks he's better than he is... butterfield more effective in this role second half

 

Whitehead 7 decent defensive performance... usual couple of misplaced passes but nothing serious... could have been more forward minded on occasions

 

Butterfield 6 not his best game tonite... not a number 10 or second striker and looked more effective in the deeper role second half

 

Adomah 7 couple of goals from bad defensive errors... nearly fluffed the second blasting it straight at the keeper... one of the few willing to run at defenders

 

Ledesma 5 poor game from manny tonite... struggled to get in the game and little came off for him... looked dangerous for about 5 mins at start of second half

 

Graham 6 first half was another tireless performance chasing nothing against overwhelming odds... looked better second half with more support but not a long term solution... not a target man like juke who was more effective in this thankless role... system needs to adapt to give strikers more support or our strikers will never score

 

Tomlin 6 few nice tricks and touches early in second half but otherwise looked off the pace

 

Main 5 barely touched the ball

 

Williams 7 managed to make an impression in the 5 mins he was on the pitch with some nice touches and interplay... looks like some regular football might have had a positive effect

 

That's a joke, right?

 

if not it's the most stupid thing I've ever seen on here:D

 

Steady on chaps... from where I was stood... dead centre row v... it looked like he smashed it through the keeper rather than try and aim for the corners... sorry but there aren't any tv replays when you buy a ticket

 

Great way to encourage new posters as well... I won't bother going to the effort next time

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest ziggy15

Fair point lad, take no notice of my reply anyway. I don't count being with the other lot and was more watching the *** that gave it him in the first place. Also wasn't behind the goal so didn't have your view as you point out, and even I think it's a better strike than I first thought, but only as you said with the benefit of a replay. Keep on posting, I'll have retired from posting on Oneboro for the next 6 months or so in a day or two anyway, it being only a twice a year visit for me. Back to the nut jobs at DATM all too soon!!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest beamishboro

It looked a great strike to be fair to Albert:cool:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Whilst Adomah's second was due to a defensive error. I was very impressed with Graham's peel off to the left. This left the centre back with a problem and whilst the split second of indecision was just that a split second Adomah was through. Excellent work

 

The Well's goal was worth the admission money on its own. I could see from the stand the opportunity. How he saw it I don't know. He had only a small window of goal to aim at and to hit it exactly right was a remarkable achievement.

 

Williams looked a different player. I do wonder if he is the number 10 we're all hoping Tomlin will be. He has always had the skill. His application has been inconsistent.

 

Ledesma was frustrating. He is either very good and a match winner or falling over and claiming fouls left right and centre. Yesterday he was the latter.

 

I found the match entertaining but that was partly due to the errors both sides perpetrated whilst displaying wonderful levels of individual skill and 4 goals to boot

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest ziggy15

Nice post mcgannd, so that was why Clarky was back-pedalling so fast he almost joined you in the stand. It always amazes me the different views one gets from local press and Managers etc, but doesn't surprise me, let alone the fans supporting the same team who sometimes don't sound as though they were at the same match. Having got home and seen the gazette, first thing I noticed was that they put Towns goals down to two gifts / errors / defensive mistakes. I suppose in their own way they were, lets be honest mistakes somewhere are often the cause of goals, but after the mistakes there was still plenty to do, and no one could even call Wells even a half chance. Adomahs 2nd too required more work than I'd initially thought being at the game. I guess if they were gifts, then our gifts to brag a bit were better than yours, and a lot more comical. Smithies even had a practice run in the 3rd minute, before they got it right in the 10th. Town, the team that keep on giving.

Us oldies either have rose tinted spectacles or get stuff wrong. I'm sure back in the day, MOM just used to be the best guy on the pitch, not like now where every team chooses their own as do the local press. I am going back to the Jimmy Greaves era etc, so could well be wrong, but still in my own way would prefer that. If a guy rips you to shreds, scores three or four, then for me he's MOM whoever he plays for. ( Or defends like Moore against Brazil and Pele ) Tuesday it would have been Wells, superb goal, made the first, worked his socks off all on his own, but when we lost at home 2-4 to Blackburn it would have been Jordan Rhodes, not as ex Town but because he did what it says on the tin, and stuck 3 past us. RIGHT, that's my lot until the next time, nice chatting and meeting a few lads at the game, see you in 6 months or so and enjoy the rest of the season. We should both survive, but I worry about our lot more than you. Both tough games this weekend in the same direction. We're at Reading, who lets face it will bounce straight back after the home loss to Barnsley. Thanks for that Barnsley.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


  • Latest Posts

    • Don't be impressed then, just be happy with a 7-0 win like I said. In the past 18 months England have made it to the World Cup semi finals and the Nations League finals.  That's better than a lot of good teams including - Spain, Belgium, Argentina, Germany, Italy and plenty of others.  We lost to Croatia after extra time in a game we probably should have won by half time and Holland after extra time in a game that we could have won but obviously didn't.  To get to the Nations League finals we had to beat both Spain and Croatia and to get to the World Cup semi finals we had to beat both Colombia and Sweden, who are both decent sides.  I think we're a better team now than we were in the World Cup as well.  We lost to Belgium in the group stage and then again the third place play off but we changed the team for both of those games, rightly or wrongly.  So whilst we did lose the games, we also didn't give either of them our best shot. Against the mighty Kosovo we won 5-3, my memory is fine.  Winning and scoring 5 goals sounds pretty good to me.  The mighty Kosovo have lost twice this year - to us and 2-1 against Czech Republic.  They've also beaten the Czech Republic and drawn with Denmark so they aren't a terrible side by any means. France have won a few trophies over the past few decades.  They've also been a better team than us over the last few decades as have Spain so that seems fair enough to me. Our much lauded attacking line up has done fine unless we don't count putting 3 past Spain and beating Croatia?  During the world cup we weren't playing like this so it's really only post the world cup that we've had the opportunity to see it in action and so far it's done pretty well.  When it gets tested against better teams next year we'll see how it goes then of course. We've put 3 past Spain, 5 past Czech Republic, 6 and 4 past Bulgaria, 5 and 7 past Montenegro and 5 past Kosovo in the last year or so.  I'm not sure it's fair to call them all minnows and if you look around there aren't many teams doing that with the same regularity.  Montenegro the other night weren't a pub side, we are the only team who have stuffed them over the past 3 or 4 years and that includes games against Denmark, Poland, Romania, Czech Republic, Hungary, Turkey and Serbia.  We're a much better side than them but they aren't hopeless and have been competitive against decent sides other than us. I don't see the relevance between a video game on the easiest setting and England.  We're not playing San Marino, Andorra etc, the teams we are playing are better than that, and as I pointed out above, we've done ok even in competitive games against good opposition.
    • Cardiff appoint ex Miillwall boss Neil Harris as their new manager. 
    • Ayala was identified by Mowbray and the loan signing went through at the time of his sacking, he definitely wasn't a Venus signing. Karanka was in charge when we signed him permanently but he had nothing to do with us identifying Ayala initially. 
    • Sorry @Erimus74. Did not see your post. I dont think any are out of contract in jan but following 6 are out of contract come the summer.  Shotton, Ayala, Friend, Howson Johnson, Rudy. Suggestion is Clayton could be 7th one also out of contract but we might have an option to extend his. That option lies with us and not Clayton apparently.
    • Totally agree @wilsoncgp. I am also at a loss to explain reason why but i am also not too bothered why other clubs are not going for him because given his stats for last few season and fact he has 6 months left on his contract means the financial risk attached with him could not be lower. He already has 9 goals and 6 assists from midfield this season meaning he almost averaging a goal/assist every game. And as @DanFromDownSouth said. He is exactly the type of player our team currently lacks imo.
×
×
  • Create New...