I certainly categorise him as a huge disappointment. When we signed him he was coming with the reputation of being one of the best midfielders in the league - he had 3 full seasons in the Premier league as a regular starter, had a good goalscoring record at this level and was very well regarded by both Leeds and Norwich fans.
But he's been bang average for us. Decent at times, certainly not our worst player but also never excelled like he did in previous teams. There are caveats - the quality of players around him, the managerial instability and quality etc. But it still doesn't distract from the fact that he's played below his ability for pretty much the entire time he's been here.
However, he has shown that ability before on a long term, consistent basis which is why I'm happier to give him another chance under Warnock next season ahead of the likes of saville, mcnair and wing - despite the fact that he is 32 now.
im sure he will be looked as hes pretty much our only winger atm, also he performed great again back at oxford. Also in Warnocks interview he talked about one of the main things he enjoys is making improving players, so i recon browne will fit in that description.
Yeah, I've been wondering that myself. All I can think is that people are making allowances for him not being a defender and as such are then convincing themselves that his displays at the back have been better than they are and therefore that he is better than he is.