Jump to content
oneBoro Forum

Has the academy production line broke down?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 304
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I totally agree Naisby. I was dead set against the change from reserve league to under 21 league from the start and I'll stand by it. Players coming through need to be playing well for a reserve side against experienced pros, and when their chance comes, they ought to be impressing and knocking on the managers door.

 

All the current system does is put another layer between youth and 1st team football. It somehow makes the youth team players less credible in the eyes of the first team manager.

 

If you look at the system in Spain, the big clubs have reserve teams that compete in the leagues below.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I totally agree Naisby. I was dead set against the change from reserve league to under 21 league from the start and I'll stand by it. Players coming through need to be playing well for a reserve side against experienced pros, and when their chance comes, they ought to be impressing and knocking on the managers door.

 

All the current system does is put another layer between youth and 1st team football. It somehow makes the youth team players less credible in the eyes of the first team manager.

 

If you look at the system in Spain, the big clubs have reserve teams that compete in the leagues below.

 

They also only have 2 profesional leauges and then one semi profesional. England have 4 profesional and 2 semi profesional. In what leauges should the reserve teams start?

Link to post
Share on other sites

The issue with the youth set up is that you are playing with peers. To really improve you need to play with people better than you. With the old reserve system you were surrounded by better players. You then raise your game to their level or you don't. Being the best player year after year doesn't help a player development but can help their value.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I totally agree Naisby. I was dead set against the change from reserve league to under 21 league from the start and I'll stand by it. Players coming through need to be playing well for a reserve side against experienced pros, and when their chance comes, they ought to be impressing and knocking on the managers door.

 

All the current system does is put another layer between youth and 1st team football. It somehow makes the youth team players less credible in the eyes of the first team manager.

 

If you look at the system in Spain, the big clubs have reserve teams that compete in the leagues below.

 

They also only have 2 profesional leauges and then one semi profesional. England have 4 profesional and 2 semi profesional. In what leauges should the reserve teams start?

 

Sorry LS, I didn't phrase that comment brilliantly.... I mentioned the Spanish system to highlight AK's mindset, he comes from a culture where the reserve teams are important and provide the next string of players when needed.

 

I firmly believe that there should be a reserve team league that is independent of the first team league. I'm pretty certain we had this debate a couple of years back.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Its ok, just wanted to point out the difference :)

 

I am sure a system like that would work eventually in England too but would take some time.

 

I do like the new u-21 system but I see it can have some bad outcomes too

Link to post
Share on other sites

aye, oldschool myself too.  id prefer two teams  ....our first team and mbro reserves  and below that an academy.

first team....championship

reserve team...reserve league

academy players can step up to the reserve team (as can first team stepdown) if good or bad.

 

all this under 15.17 19 21 stuff is confusing as it isnt strictly age adhered.

 

NO Research was done into this btw.... its simply a personal view.(how sad i felt the need to add that ;) )

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wasn't the reserve ream system abolished because financially weighted teams like Chelsea were hoovering up all the talent just so other teams couldn't get them? That's why they ended up with the likes of Wayne Bridge, Steve Sidwell and Damien Duff not getting a look in.

I like the 25-man squad system, but perhaps the development league rules could be tweaked to allow 5 or 6 Over 21s to play, rather than the 3(?) it is at the moment.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The issue with the youth set up is that you are playing with peers. To really improve you need to play with people better than you. With the old reserve system you were surrounded by better players. You then raise your game to their level or you don't. Being the best player year after year doesn't help a player development but can help their value.

 

I'm not sure where yourself and others get the idea that the old reserve league was full of 'better players' or as others think it was full of 'experienced professionals' it wasnt.

 

Look back 5 years in the Boro reserves/U21s youth forum on this website. I did a few reports back then.

Boro vs S***horpe - Ripley, Pilatos, Oliver, Hines, Reach, Luke Williams, Smallwood, Thomson, Fowler, Halliday, Main, Subs Brobbel, Atkinson, Jackson, Wyke, Coddington.

Only really experienced professional in the Boro line up was Thomson. 

 

S***horpe had a very young side that night. Looking at the other games in that time Boro played young sides as did the opponents.

 

Its not much different now over age players can play and do often play for all sides especially when coming back from injury or when not fancied by the manager (but often loans get them out before reserve football is used) 

 

The last side i remember at reserve level playing a fair few first team squad players was hartlepool against us and they whooped us on a cold, wet windy night.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Posts

    • I'm surprised that Gestede has actually managed 178 games in his career so I just checked and according to Wiki he has managed 284 games over his entire career which for a 32 year old isn't many. Smith at three years younger has played 410 games so at least he may be available for selection instead of sending in a sick note. They both seem to have a 1:4 ratio which isn't great but much more useful if fit and available and that's before we consider the respective costs involved for fees and wages.
    • There was an astonishing story in the Guardian about why Magath bombed at Fulham, shortly after he left. It sounds like we dodged a bullet by not appointing him. https://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2014/sep/20/fulham-farewell-magath-felix-madcap That said, it's extremely narrow-minded and parochial to dismiss a German manager because he'd supposedly turn the town of Middlesbrough into an enclave of ze Faterland. Wonder what changed in the run-up to Aitor's arrival?
    • Yeah, you have no idea. I had it all written out, it's crazy. I also just realised I have the very last scenario wrong. If Denmark win 1-0, Finland lose 2-1 and Denmark get only 1 disciplinary point more than Finland, Denmark will still finish 2nd. It's only if Denmark get 2 or more greater than Finland that they will finish 3rd. Basically, that scenario with those scores and only 1 yellow card more than Finland goes all the way to the last tiebreaker. Which goes all the way back to the qualifying groups and compares position, then points, goal difference etc. But even though Finland got more points than Denmark in qualifying (they finished in the same position), Finland got 6 of those points against the 6th placed team. Because some of the groups have 6 teams (Finland) and some groups have 5 (Denmark), they re-do the tables as if nobody ever played the 6th placed team. So Denmark would retain their 16 points, Finland would drop from 18 to 12 as if they never played Liechtenstein.
    • Well it could be, if they haven't been recommending the kind of players he is looking for. Or else it speaks to more poor communication if they haven't been given the right instructions. Some people adopt the, "If you want something done properly...do it yourself..." philosophy if they find others aren't doing what they want. Maybe thats whats going on here...unless Warnock has had the same approach at his other clubs. 🤷‍♂️  
    • come on the danes, the incentive must be if you get though in second. wales in the last 16. surely u guys can beat that lot.  Danish power come on u reds.

×
×
  • Create New...